OT: What book are you reading at the moment?

I tend to agree with you re Doors Open ( and I had a nagging feeling that I'd read something similar before ) - was still enjoyable enough to finish though.

I don't agree with your assessment of Fox, mind. His problems with authority stemmed from being manipulated by his superiors and weren't apparent prior to that. I think your perception of him as a misfit might be because he's alienated by not boozing unless you spotted something I didn't (quite plausibly!).

Have you read Blood Hunt? That's another non-Rebus one I read recently, but I have a feeling it was written a while ago under a pseudonym and has recently been re-issued as a Rankin. Full of Seppo spellings for some reason..

You may be right about Fox - I read it virtually when it came out, some of the details are a bit hazy now. But I think - though Rankin has characterised Rebus as being a bit older, a bit more cynical (slightly) and more conservative than himself - he has always been basically on Rebus's side vis-a-vis his superiors. So the "subjective" difference as against Fox doesn't feel that large. If you see what I mean.

Blood Hunt, yes, by "Jack Harvey". I think I have probably just about read all the fiction Rankin has published. Even the graphic novel.

Blood Hunt. Wasn't great. It's clear that as Jack Harvey, the author was lusting for more of an "action thriller" persona ... also in some early books seeking the cast of a psychological thriller - the first three Rebus included, also the early "The Flood", which FWIW I thought against expectations (and damning reviews) was a good read and (surprisingly) plausibly constructed, some elements like The Falls, if you know that one. And also at least one spy novel.

You will know that Rankin never set out to be a "crime writer", but a writer of imaginative fiction - but couldn't escape the narrow shelf, and grew more towards it, while trying to smuggle in as much topography, psychology and character portraiture as he could. He resisted for a while partly because he wasn't primarily interested in "crime" as such, partly because of the financial lure but status belittlement and condescension in literary circles towards "genre fiction".

Again FWIW, of the non-Rebus novels - and while aware you can't do this legitimately, each book has its strengths and weaknesses - I would rank them in this descending order:

1. Bleeding Hearts (very good indeed - up with the best of Rebus)
2. Witch Hunt - slightly preposterous maybe, but gripping, well written
3. The Flood
4. Blood Hunt - hmmmm. A bit daft. A lot of running around, relentless car driving, etc. But a bit like a Steven Seagal movie in print.
5. Watchman - well, it has its moments I guess, but like John Le Carre' on a very bad day for the most part. I'd prefer Prohias' Spy vs Spy to be honest.


phew.

Simon Pegg's autobiography.

I'm about eight shits in.

Jontyh wrote:I tend to agree with you re Doors Open ( and I had a nagging feeling that I'd read something similar before ) - was still enjoyable enough to finish though.

I don't agree with your assessment of Fox, mind. His problems with authority stemmed from being manipulated by his superiors and weren't apparent prior to that. I think your perception of him as a misfit might be because he's alienated by not boozing unless you spotted something I didn't (quite plausibly!).

Have you read Blood Hunt? That's another non-Rebus one I read recently, but I have a feeling it was written a while ago under a pseudonym and has recently been re-issued as a Rankin. Full of Seppo spellings for some reason..

read the second Fox one a couple of weeks ago. Looks like he might have completely retired Rebus.

Busy with A Dance with Dragons. Number 5 in Ice abd Fire.

Switching between 'How I Escaped My Certain Fate' by Stewart Lee and 'The Anubis Gates' by Tim Powers continuing my steampunk fetish... it's not serving me well at all. I should just pick one, but I'm such a greedy baby.

Oh yes, also reading an old Elizabeth George I downloeded to iPad.

taipan wrote:Oh yes, also reading an old Elizabeth George I downloeded to iPad.

I've read all EG's novels.

Currently reading 'My Policeman' which is set in Brighton, England.

Red wrote:

taipan wrote:Oh yes, also reading an old Elizabeth George I downloeded to iPad.

I've read all EG's novels.

Currently reading 'My Policeman' which is set in Brighton, England.

I've read most of them but missed a couple in the middle.

Author?

taipan wrote:

Red wrote:

taipan wrote:Oh yes, also reading an old Elizabeth George I downloeded to iPad.

I've read all EG's novels.

Currently reading 'My Policeman' which is set in Brighton, England.

I've read most of them but missed a couple in the middle.

Author?

Bethan Roberts. It got good reviews, am enjoying it - well written too.

taipan wrote:

Red wrote:

taipan wrote:Oh yes, also reading an old Elizabeth George I downloeded to iPad.

I've read all EG's novels.

Currently reading 'My Policeman' which is set in Brighton, England.

I've read most of them but missed a couple in the middle.

Author?

BTW, if you like EG you might also enjoy other Brtish crime authors Peter Robinson and Deborah Crombie if you haven't come across them. Obviously people read Ian Rankin.

And a couple of SA crime writers I enjoy are Deon Meyer and Margie Orford.

The new Alan Moore book 'Jerusalem' is set in the place where upon you'd find me living. Sexy, eh? That should sell a few more copies.

Red wrote:

taipan wrote:

Red wrote:

taipan wrote:Oh yes, also reading an old Elizabeth George I downloeded to iPad.

I've read all EG's novels.

Currently reading 'My Policeman' which is set in Brighton, England.

I've read most of them but missed a couple in the middle.

Author?

BTW, if you like EG you might also enjoy other Brtish crime authors Peter Robinson and Deborah Crombie if you haven't come across them. Obviously people read Ian Rankin.

And a couple of SA crime writers I enjoy are Deon Meyer and Margie Orford.

Tried Robinson, but preferred Reginald Hill, but he's just snuffed it.

taipan wrote:

Red wrote:

taipan wrote:

Red wrote:

taipan wrote:Oh yes, also reading an old Elizabeth George I downloeded to iPad.

I've read all EG's novels.

Currently reading 'My Policeman' which is set in Brighton, England.

I've read most of them but missed a couple in the middle.

Author?

BTW, if you like EG you might also enjoy other Brtish crime authors Peter Robinson and Deborah Crombie if you haven't come across them. Obviously people read Ian Rankin.

And a couple of SA crime writers I enjoy are Deon Meyer and Margie Orford.

Tried Robinson, but preferred Reginald Hill, but he's just snuffed it.

Didn't read Hill but watched his tv series.

You should try Hill. The books are way better than the series. You don't get the interaction and the humour between Dalziel, Pascoe, Ellie and Wield in the series.

Also the books are very politically incorrect.

taipan wrote:You should try Hill. The books are way better than the series. You don't get the interaction and the humour between Dalziel, Pascoe, Ellie and Wield in the series.

Also the books are very politically incorrect.

I have one on my shelf but have never got around to reading it. I've a backlog of so many it's frustrating and then they keep publishing more!